MIG vs TIG vs Stick Welding: Differences and the Best Welder for Each
If you have not settled on MIG, TIG or stick yet, buy the Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MP. It runs all three processes plus flux-core from one 120V machine, so you can learn which process fits your work before you spend on a dedicated welder. Lincoln rates it at 95A at 60% duty cycle for MIG, 115A at 60% for DC TIG and 80A at 60% for stick, at 34.5 lbs.
Get Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MPAlready know your process? The MIG pick is the Hobart Handler 140EZ, the TIG pick is the AHP AlphaTIG 203Xi and the stick pick is the Hobart Stickmate 160. Each one, and who should buy something else, is below. The differences between the three processes follow as the how-to-choose guide.
The Best Welder for Each Process
| Pick | Process | Input | Maker’s rated output | Weight | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MP | MIG, flux-core, stick, DC TIG | 120V | 95A at 60% (MIG) | 34.5 lbs | 3 years |
| Hobart Handler 140EZ | MIG, flux-core | 120V | 90A at 30% | 53 lbs | Hobart 5/3/1 |
| AHP AlphaTIG 203Xi | AC/DC TIG, AC/DC stick | 120/240V | 200A at 60% (240V TIG) | 40 lbs | 3 years |
| Hobart Stickmate 160 | DC stick | 120/240V | 160A at 15% (240V) | 10.6 lbs | Hobart 5/3/1 |
| Miller Multimatic 220 AC/DC | MIG, flux-core, stick, AC/DC TIG | 120/240V | 200A at 20% (240V MIG) | 56 lbs | 3 years |
The picks were chosen on three criteria: the machine covers the work its process is bought for (thickness, metals, input power), it is easy to set up for someone new to that process, and its rated output and warranty are published by the maker. These picks were not tested; this is what the makers’ specifications and included-equipment lists show. Every figure on this page is the maker’s.
Best Multi-Process Welder If You Have Not Chosen: Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MP
The POWER MIG 140 MP is the pick for a reader who searched “MIG vs TIG vs stick” because the answer is still open. One box lets you run a MIG bead on clean sheet steel, burn stick rods on a rusty trailer outside in dry weather, and try DC TIG on stainless, and it plugs into household 120V power on a 20A circuit, the fuse or breaker size Lincoln’s manual calls for.
Why it wins:
- All three processes in one machine. Lincoln lists MIG at 30-140A, DC TIG at 10-120A and stick at 25-90A, plus flux-cored wire for gasless welding outdoors.
- Usable duty cycle on 120V. Lincoln rates it at 95A at 60% for MIG, 115A at 60% for TIG and 80A at 60% for stick. A 60% rating means six minutes of welding in every ten at that output, which is more than most home projects ask of it.
- Easy to set up. Lincoln’s spec sheet lists a single button for process selection, two-knob operation and tool-less drive roll changes.
- Light enough to carry. Lincoln lists the weight at 34.5 lbs.
- What comes in the box. A Magnum PRO 100L MIG gun with a 10 ft. cable, a Harris gas regulator for argon/CO2 blends, a stick electrode holder with a 10 ft. cable, a work clamp and sample spools of MIG and flux-cored wire.
- Warranty. Lincoln’s equipment warranty covers its welding machines for 3 years, parts and labor. Lincoln’s product page carries a California Proposition 65 warning for cancer and reproductive harm.
Who should buy something else: the 140 MP is a 120V-only machine, and its TIG is DC only, so it will not TIG weld aluminum. A TIG torch and foot pedal are optional accessories, not in the box, and MIG welding aluminum needs Lincoln’s optional Magnum PRO 100SG spool gun. Its 90A stick ceiling also limits the rod sizes you can run. If you already know you will weld aluminum with TIG, or you have a 240V outlet and want more power, the Miller Multimatic 220 AC/DC below is the better buy. If you know you only want MIG, the Hobart Handler 140EZ does that one job, with EZ Mode setup and Hobart’s 5/3/1 warranty.
Get Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MPBest MIG Welder: Hobart Handler 140EZ
Buy the Handler 140EZ if you already know MIG is your process: garage fabrication, brackets, trailers, auto body panels and general repair on mild steel.
Why it wins:
- EZ Mode setup. You set the material thickness on one knob and the wire diameter on the other, and the machine sets the parameters. For a first MIG welder, getting voltage and wire speed right is the hardest part, and this takes it away. Manual mode with infinite voltage control is there when you want to fine-tune.
- Covers the common home range. Hobart lists a 30-140A output range and rates it to weld 24 gauge up to 3/16 in. mild steel in a single pass on 120V, with thicker material possible in multiple passes and proper material prep.
- Rated output. Hobart rates it at 90A at 18.5V at 30% duty cycle.
- Built for MIG. Hobart lists an industrial cast aluminum wire drive, a Quick Select drive roll with grooves for two sizes of solid wire and one for flux-cored wire, and a hub that takes 4 or 8 in. spools.
- Ready for gas out of the box. It ships with a 10 ft. MIG gun, a built-in gas solenoid and a dual-gauge regulator with hose. Hobart’s chart calls for 75% argon / 25% CO2 on mild steel.
- Aluminum when you need it. It is spool gun ready with no extra interface; Hobart’s SpoolRunner 150 is sold separately.
- Warranty. Hobart’s 5/3/1 warranty: five years on transformers, stabilizers and main rectifiers, three years on PC boards and drive systems, one year on guns.
Who should buy something else: the 140EZ does MIG and flux-core only, so it will never weld stick or TIG. Hobart notes it is not recommended for use with engine-driven welders or standalone generators, so it needs mains power rather than a generator. Hobart’s manual calls for a 20 or 30A individual branch circuit with a NEMA 5-20R receptacle. At 53 lbs it is also heavier than the multi-process 140 MP. For dual-voltage MIG machines that go thicker, see the best MIG welders for beginners.
Get Hobart Handler 140EZBest TIG Welder: AHP AlphaTIG 203Xi
Buy the AlphaTIG 203Xi if you want TIG for precision work, thin stainless, chromoly or aluminum, and you want a machine you will not outgrow while you learn.
Why it wins:
- AC and DC TIG. AC is what TIG welds aluminum with. AHP lists adjustable AC frequency (20-200 Hz) and AC balance (20-80% electrode positive).
- Pulse on both AC and DC. AHP lists pulse frequency of 0.5-250 Hz on DC and 0.5-150 Hz on AC, which helps control heat and warping on thin parts.
- Low-amp start for thin material. AHP lists a minimum of 5A on DC and 20A on AC.
- Dual voltage. AHP rates it at 200A TIG and 180A stick on 240V, and 150A TIG and 125A stick on 120V, with a 240V-to-120V plug adapter in the box.
- Duty cycle. AHP rates it at 200A at 60% duty cycle for TIG on 240V.
- Ready to TIG. It ships with a Nova 17 TIG torch, a foot pedal, a stick electrode holder, a work clamp and an argon regulator. Tungsten is not included.
- Easy settings. AHP’s Rapid Set function suggests an amperage range from the tungsten size and metal thickness you enter, and does the same for stick rods by class and diameter.
- Warranty. AHP gives a 3-year parts and labor warranty.
Who should buy something else: the AlphaTIG 203Xi has no wire feeder, so it cannot MIG weld. AHP lists its aluminum maximum at 1/8 in. on 120V and 1/4 in. on 240V, with multi-pass technique beyond that, so thicker aluminum needs a 240V circuit. If you mostly want fast welds on mild steel, MIG is the better process and the Handler 140EZ is the better buy. More TIG choices are in the best TIG welders for beginners.
Get AHP AlphaTIG 203XiBest Stick Welder: Hobart Stickmate 160
Buy the Stickmate 160 if your welding is farm equipment, repair work or dirty and rusty steel, where stick is the process that keeps working. Hobart’s owner’s manual rates it IP21S and says it is designed for indoor use and not intended to be used or stored outside, so weld with it under cover and keep it dry.
Why it wins:
- DC output. Hobart notes DC stick welding gives fewer arc outages, less sticking, less spatter and better arc control.
- Dual voltage without tools. It plugs into 120V or 240V through the included adapter cord. Hobart lists 10-80A on 120V and 10-160A on 240V.
- Thickness. Hobart rates it to weld mild steel up to 1/8 in. on 120V and 3/8 in. on 240V.
- Portable. Hobart lists a net weight of 10.6 lbs, and it comes with a shoulder strap, so it goes to the work.
- Simple to set. One knob and a digital display, adjusting in 1-amp steps.
- Runs the common rods. Hobart lists ideal performance for most 6011, 6013 and 7018 rods, and notes that 6010 is not recommended for open root welding. On 240V Hobart lists 1/16 to 5/32 in. rods, with some limitations on 5/32 in. rods based on amperage; on 120V it lists 1/16 to 1/8 in., with some limitations on 3/32 in. rods and very limited use of 1/8 in. rods.
- Warranty. Hobart’s 5/3/1 industrial warranty.
Who should buy something else: Hobart rates it at 160A at 15% duty cycle on 240V (and 80A at 15% on 120V). That is plenty for repair welds, but a welder running long passes at the top of its range will wait on it. Stick also leaves slag to chip, so for clean, fast indoor work on thin steel the Handler 140EZ is the better buy. More stick machines, including heavier shop units, are in the best stick welders guide.
Get Hobart Stickmate 160When Paying More Is Worth It: Miller Multimatic 220 AC/DC
The Multimatic 220 AC/DC is the multi-process machine to buy if you know you will TIG weld aluminum and you have, or will add, a 240V outlet. It is the step up from the POWER MIG 140 MP for a buyer who wants every process at full strength in one box.
- AC/DC TIG, MIG, flux-core and DC stick. Miller lists MIG at 30-230A, TIG at 20-210A and stick at 30-200A on 240V.
- Rated output. On 240V, Miller rates it at 200A at 20% duty cycle for MIG, 210A at 20% for TIG and 200A at 15% for stick. On 120V it is rated at 105A at 60% for MIG and 130A at 40% for TIG.
- Thickness. Miller lists MIG on 24 gauge to 3/8 in. steel, TIG on 24 gauge to 1/4 in. steel and aluminum, and stick on 16 gauge to 3/8 in. steel.
- Everything to TIG in the box. It ships with a MIG gun, two flow gauge regulators for argon or argon/CO2 mix and, unlike the 140 MP, a Weldcraft A-150 TIG torch and a foot control. The MIG gun and TIG torch can stay connected, and Miller’s QuickTech sets polarity and process when you pull the trigger or press the pedal.
- Generator use. Miller states full output on generators of 10,000 watts or more; smaller generators will limit output.
- Warranty. Miller warrants the welder for three years, parts and labor; the gun for 90 days, parts only.
Who should not buy it: anyone who does not need AC TIG. At 56 lbs it is heavier, its full output needs 240V, and a spool gun for aluminum MIG is still sold separately. A hobbyist who will mostly MIG and stick weld steel gets what they need from the POWER MIG 140 MP.
Get Miller Multimatic 220 AC/DCWhat Is Not Worth the Money
- A TIG machine as your only welder for farm and field repair. TIG needs clean metal and still air. For rusty equipment outdoors, a stick welder costs less and does the job.
- A gas MIG setup if every weld you make is outside. Wind blows away the shielding gas. Run flux-cored wire (both MIG picks above do) or buy a stick welder.
- An AC/DC multi-process machine if you will never weld aluminum. The AC TIG is what you pay extra for in the Multimatic 220 AC/DC. Without aluminum on your list, the POWER MIG 140 MP covers the rest.
How to Choose: The Differences Between MIG, TIG and Stick
The picks above follow from what each process does well. If you are still deciding, this is what separates them.
MIG Welding (GMAW)
MIG stands for Metal Inert Gas; the technical name is Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW). A wire electrode feeds continuously through the gun, the arc melts it into the joint, and shielding gas flows through the nozzle to protect the molten pool. On mild steel that gas is usually a 75% argon / 25% CO2 mix, which is what Hobart’s chart for the Handler 140EZ specifies.
The wire is both the electrode and the filler metal. You never stop to change a rod or feed a filler by hand, so you pull the trigger and go. That is why MIG is the fastest process to learn and the fastest to weld with.
Flux-core (FCAW) uses a tubular wire filled with flux instead of solid wire and a gas bottle. The flux makes its own shielding as it burns, so it works outdoors and in wind. Both MIG picks above run flux-cored wire.
TIG Welding (GTAW)
TIG stands for Tungsten Inert Gas, technically Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW). A tungsten electrode that does not melt creates the arc, and you feed a separate filler rod into the pool with the other hand. Pure argon shields the weld.
TIG is a two-handed process. One hand holds the torch, the other feeds filler, and a foot pedal (or fingertip control) changes amperage while you weld. That gives you the finest control over heat of any manual process, and it demands the most coordination.
Stick Welding (SMAW)
Stick welding, formally Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW), is one of the oldest and simplest arc processes. A flux-coated rod is clamped in an electrode holder; the arc melts the rod and the base metal while the coating burns off into a gas shield and a layer of slag that protects the cooling weld.
Stick needs no gas bottle and no wire feeder: a power source, an electrode holder, a ground clamp and rods. That makes it the most portable and wind-tolerant of the three.
MIG vs TIG vs Stick: Side-by-Side
| Factor | MIG (GMAW) | TIG (GTAW) | Stick (SMAW) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Difficulty | Easiest: pull trigger, move gun | Hardest: both hands plus foot pedal | Moderate: one hand, technique matters |
| Speed | Fast: continuous wire feed | Slow: filler fed by hand | Medium: rod changes interrupt |
| Weld appearance | Clean, little spatter | Finest of the three | Rougher; slag to chip off |
| Metals | Steel, stainless; aluminum with a spool gun | Steel, stainless, chromoly; aluminum with AC | Steel, stainless and cast iron with the right rod |
| Outdoor use | Poor with gas; good with flux-core | Poor: wind disrupts the gas | Excellent: no external gas |
| Portability | Low with a gas bottle | Low: gas bottle and filler rods | High: machine and rods only |
| Dirty or rusty metal | Needs clean metal | Needs very clean metal | Most forgiving |
| Best pick on this page | Hobart Handler 140EZ | AHP AlphaTIG 203Xi | Hobart Stickmate 160 |
Learning Curve
MIG is the easiest to learn. The wire feeds itself and the gas flows on its own; your job is gun angle, travel speed and distance from the work. The hardest part for a beginner is matching voltage and wire speed to the metal thickness, which is exactly what setup aids like Hobart’s EZ Mode on the Handler 140EZ address. Once the settings are right, the technique is forgiving.
TIG is the hardest. You hold the torch at the right angle and distance, feed filler at a steady rhythm, control amperage with your foot, watch the pool and keep your travel speed even, all at once. Aluminum is harder again, because it needs AC TIG and a different technique. The payoff is the most precise, cleanest welds of any manual process, and the control you learn improves your MIG and stick welding too.
Stick sits in between. You manage one hand and no pedal, but holding a steady arc length as the rod burns down takes practice, and the flux and slag make the puddle harder to read than with MIG or TIG. Vertical and overhead welds are where stick gets difficult, and doing them well is what separates hobby welds from structural ones.
Weld Quality and Strength
No process makes inherently stronger welds. Done with the right procedure, filler and joint preparation, MIG, TIG and stick can all meet structural requirements. What differs is the kind of mistake each invites.
MIG gives clean, consistent beads on thin to medium steel. Its typical defects are porosity from poor gas coverage (drafts, a wrong flow rate, dirty metal), cold lap when settings are too low or travel too fast, and burn-through on thin sheet when settings are too hot.
TIG gives the highest-quality welds of the three: low distortion from precise heat control, excellent root penetration and the familiar “stacked dimes” look. It is the process for thin material where burn-through is a risk and for work where the weld will be seen.
Stick gives robust welds with deep penetration. Low-hydrogen 7018 rods are the strong, general structural choice; 6010 and 6011 dig deep through rust and mill scale. Because the flux makes its own shield, stick is less sensitive to wind and dirty surfaces than either gas process. The trade-off is appearance: every bead needs the slag chipped and brushed off.
What Each Setup Needs Beyond the Machine
The machine is only part of the purchase. What each pick includes decides what else you buy:
- MIG (Handler 140EZ): the gun, regulator and gas hose come with it. You add a shielding gas cylinder (or use flux-cored wire with no gas), a spool of wire, a helmet and gloves.
- TIG (AlphaTIG 203Xi): the torch, foot pedal and argon regulator come with it. You add a cylinder of pure argon, tungsten electrodes, filler rods to match the metal, a helmet and thinner TIG gloves.
- Stick (Stickmate 160): the electrode holder and work clamp come with it. You add rods, a helmet, gloves, a chipping hammer and a wire brush. There is no gas to buy, which keeps running costs down.
- Multi-process (POWER MIG 140 MP): MIG gun, regulator and electrode holder come with it. TIG needs the optional torch and foot pedal plus an argon cylinder.
For every process, the makers’ manuals also call for safety glasses with side shields under the helmet, flame-resistant clothing, and ventilation or fume extraction at the arc (see ANSI Z49.1).
Best Uses for Each Process
Choose MIG when you weld mild steel in a garage or shop, you want usable welds quickly as a beginner, you do auto body sheet metal (MIG burns through thin panels less readily than stick), or you build trailers, brackets, carts and frames. MIG is also the easiest process to keep uniform over a long seam.
Choose TIG when weld quality matters most, you weld aluminum (AC TIG is the standard for it), you work thin stainless or chromoly where heat control prevents distortion, or the weld will be seen on furniture, art or a custom build.
Choose stick when you weld outdoors in wind or in remote spots, you repair farm and heavy equipment, the metal is rusty or dirty, you need the lightest and most portable setup, or you want to skip buying shielding gas.
Can One Welder Do All Three?
Yes. The POWER MIG 140 MP and the Multimatic 220 AC/DC both run MIG, flux-core, stick and TIG. The trade-off is that a multi-process machine shares one power source and one set of controls across every process, so a dedicated machine at a similar level often offers more for its one job: the AlphaTIG 203Xi has more TIG adjustment (AC frequency, balance, pulse) than the 140 MP’s DC-only TIG, and the Stickmate 160 weighs a fraction of either multi-process machine.
If you are starting out and do not know which process your projects need, a multi-process machine lets you find out. Once you know, a dedicated machine for your main process is worth adding. The best multi-process welders under $1000 guide covers more of them.
Which Process Should You Learn First?
- Start with MIG. It builds puddle control, travel speed and joint preparation without overwhelming you, and you make useful welds quickly.
- Add stick if you need portability or outdoor work. The skills carry over from MIG, and stick opens up field repair and structural work.
- Learn TIG when you want precision. With MIG and stick fundamentals in hand, TIG’s coordination is less overwhelming, and it sharpens your other welding because it forces you to read the pool.
Professional welders usually learn all three in training and then specialize. Pipe welders work mostly in TIG and stick, production shops run MIG, and precision fabricators live in TIG.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between MIG, TIG and stick welding?
MIG feeds a wire electrode through a gun with shielding gas and is the fastest and easiest to learn. TIG uses a tungsten electrode with filler fed by hand and gives the most precise welds but is the hardest to learn. Stick uses a flux-coated rod, needs no gas and works best outdoors and on dirty metal.
Which welding process is strongest?
All three can produce welds that meet the same strength requirements when done correctly. Weld strength depends on the procedure, technique, filler metal and joint design more than the process itself.
Can I MIG weld aluminum?
Yes, with a spool gun and pure argon. Soft aluminum wire feeds poorly through a standard MIG gun’s long liner, which is why the Handler 140EZ uses Hobart’s SpoolRunner 150 and the POWER MIG 140 MP uses Lincoln’s Magnum PRO 100SG, both sold separately. For serious aluminum work, AC TIG is the better process.
Is stick welding obsolete?
No. Stick welding remains essential in structural construction, pipeline work, maintenance and field repair. Its portability and tolerance of wind and dirty metal make it the right process where MIG and TIG are impractical.
What is the easiest metal to practice welding on?
Mild steel. It is forgiving with all three processes, cheap and easy to find, and it is the most commonly welded metal in hobby and professional work. Flat plate scraps make good practice coupons.
Do I need separate helmets for MIG, TIG and stick?
No. One good auto-darkening helmet works for all three, but low-amperage TIG produces a dim arc that some budget helmets fail to detect. Choose a helmet whose maker rates it for TIG at the low amperages you will use. See the best auto-darkening welding helmets guide.
Can I teach myself welding without classes?
Yes, many welders are self-taught through practice and online resources. Classes at a community college, trade school or makerspace add instruction, equipment access and structured progress, and they are most worth it for TIG.
Bottom Line
There is no single best welding process, only the best one for your work: MIG for speed and ease, TIG for precision and aluminum, stick for portability and dirty metal. If you have not chosen, the Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MP lets you weld all three on household power. If you have, buy the Hobart Handler 140EZ for MIG, the AHP AlphaTIG 203Xi for TIG or the Hobart Stickmate 160 for stick. And if aluminum TIG on 240V is in your plans, the Miller Multimatic 220 AC/DC is the pick that does it all.
Get Lincoln POWER MIG 140 MPRelated Articles
- Best MIG Welders for Beginners: more MIG picks for getting started
- Best TIG Welders for Beginners: TIG machines for learning precision work
- Best TIG Welder for Home Shop: TIG machines for a home shop
- Best Stick Welders: stick machines for portability and versatility
- Best Multi-Process Welders Under $1000: machines that do all three processes
- Welding Certification Guide: certifications for each welding process
- Flux Core vs MIG Welding: gasless versus gas MIG for outdoor work
- Inverter vs Transformer Welder: which technology powers your machine
- 110V vs 220V Welders: voltage guide for home shop and garage setups