The Best Auto Body Panel Repair Kit, Item by Item

The panel repair kit, one pick per job

Cutting out rusted body steel and welding in a patch involves seven jobs: welding thin sheet, protecting your eyes through hundreds of short tacks, taking the old panel off its spot welds, cutting and dressing metal, preparing the edges and plug holes, holding the new panel in place, and keeping corrosion out of the overlap. Each job below gets one choice and the documented reason for it. Body panels are usually 18 to 22 gauge. In the manufacturers’ standard gauge for sheet steel that is about 0.048 in, 0.036 in and 0.030 in thick, so every choice here is judged on how it handles steel that thin.

Welder: Hobart Handler 140EZ for 18 to 22 gauge steel

The Hobart Handler 140EZ is a 120-volt MIG and flux-core welder. Hobart lists mild steel from 24 gauge to 1/4 in. That bottom figure is what matters on a car: 22 gauge is thinner than most shop work, and a welder that cannot run smoothly at low current will blow holes in it. Hobart says it runs on standard 120V power, and its spec sheet says the Handler 140EZ is not recommended for use with engine-driven welders or standalone generators. The rated output is 90 amps at 30% duty cycle. Hobart’s manual warns that overuse can cause overheating: allow a cooling period, follow the rated duty cycle, reduce current or reduce duty cycle before starting to weld again, and do not block or filter airflow to the unit.

Get Hobart Handler 140EZ

For body steel, the parts that come in the box matter more than peak amps. The welder has a built-in gas solenoid and a dual-gauge regulator with hose, so you can run solid wire under shielding gas without buying a separate regulator; Hobart notes that shielding gas and safety equipment are not included. The Quick Select drive roll has two solid-wire grooves (.024 in and .030/.035 in) and one flux-core groove (.030/.035 in). Before loading .024 in wire, check which groove is marked for the smallest solid wire and fit a contact tip of the same size. Hobart’s manual says only qualified persons should install, operate, maintain and repair this equipment; keep everybody, especially children, away during operation; wearers of pacemakers and other implanted medical devices should keep away and should consult their doctor and the device manufacturer before going near arc welding, spot welding, gouging, plasma arc cutting, or induction heating operations; remove all flammables within 35 ft (10.7 m) of the welding arc, or if this is not possible, tightly cover them with approved covers; and do not weld near degreasing, cleaning or spraying operations, because the heat and rays of the arc can react with vapors to form highly toxic and irritating gases. It also carries a California Proposition 65 warning that the product can expose you to chemicals including lead, which are known to the state of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For other 120V and dual-voltage machines suited to sheet metal, see best welder for auto body.

Helmet: Lincoln Electric Viking 3350 for constant tacking

A patch panel goes in as a long run of tacks, each about a second long, spread around the seam so heat does not warp the panel. That means you strike the arc hundreds of times on one job, so the filter’s switching speed and the clarity of its light state matter more than usual. Lincoln documents the Lincoln Electric Viking 3350 with a 1/25,000 second switching speed, a variable dark shade of 5-13 and its 4C lens. The optical rating is 1/1/1/1, which Lincoln says eliminates distortion, removes blurriness, and provides uniform shade and consistent shade at all angles. Angle dependence counts when you weld a rocker or wheel arch from underneath, because a low-class filter darkens unevenly when you look through it at an angle. Lincoln’s product page carries a California Proposition 65 warning for cancer and reproductive harm.

Get Lincoln Electric Viking 3350

Removing the old metal: spotweld cutter and grinder

Factory panels are joined at their flanges by resistance spot welds. A twist drill goes straight through both layers and leaves a hole in the flange you need to weld the new panel to. Blair’s own store no longer lists the 11094; a search there for 11094 returns only the Karbon X Rotabroach Premium Spotweld Cutter Kit (11094KX). The Blair 11094 spotweld cutter is a 3/8 in cutter with a standard pilot. The pilot centers on the weld nugget and the cutter cuts a ring through the top sheet only. You stop as soon as the top layer comes free, and the flange behind is left whole. Blair makes it in the USA. Mark each nugget with a center punch first so the pilot does not wander. Blair says the cutter is for use in 3/8 in or larger drill chucks and that cutter RPM should not exceed 500 RPM.

Get Blair 11094 spotweld cutter

The DeWalt DWE402 is a 4-1/2 in angle grinder with an 11 amp motor and a no-load speed of 11,000 RPM. DeWalt’s manual says not to use it under wet conditions or in the presence of flammable liquids or gases, not to let children come into contact with it, and that supervision is required when inexperienced operators use it; always use the side handle and tighten it securely, and always wear eye protection. It does three jobs here: cutting out the rusted section with a thin cut-off wheel (never grind with the side of a cut-off wheel, DeWalt warns), cleaning the paint back to bare metal, and dressing the finished welds flush with a Type 27 flap disc. DeWalt says not to use Type 11 (flaring cup) wheels on this tool. Every wheel and disc you fit must carry a maximum speed rating of at least 11,000 RPM. Do not operate the tool for long periods: DeWalt warns that vibration may cause permanent injury to fingers, hands and arms, and says to use gloves, take frequent rest periods and limit daily time of use. DeWalt says guards must be used with all grinding wheels, cutting wheels, sanding flap discs, wire brushes and wire wheels (the tool may be used without a guard only when sanding with conventional sanding discs), and a closed, two-sided cutting wheel guard is required when using abrasive cutting wheels or diamond coated cutting wheels. The DWE402 comes with a 4-1/2 in One-Touch (T27) guard.

Get DeWalt DWE402

Edges and plug holes: Astro Pneumatic 608PT

A lap-joint repair needs two things a drill cannot make. One is plug-weld holes in the new panel where the factory spot welds were. The other is an offset step, or joggle, along the edge so the new panel slides under the old one and both faces end up flush. The Astro Pneumatic 608PT is a pistol-grip air tool that does both. One end punches an 8 mm hole, about 5/16 in, which is a common size for plug welds in body sheet. The other end presses the offset flange. Astro also sells the 605PT with a 5.5 mm punch, but the 8 mm hole leaves more room to fill a plug weld on 18 to 20 gauge steel. The tool runs on shop air, so you also need a compressor and hose. Astro specifies 90-120 psi (6.21-8.28 bar) air pressure, a 3/8 in (10 mm) I.D. hose and 4 cfm average air consumption. Astro rates the punch capacity and crimping capacity at 1.6 mm (1/16 in), so check the steel thickness before punching heavier inner structure.

Get Astro Pneumatic 608PT

Holding the panel: Cleco K4S50-1 kit

Cleco fasteners are spring-loaded temporary pins. Each one goes through matching holes and pulls the two sheets together, so the panel stays exactly where you fitted it while you tack it. The Cleco K4S50-1 kit from MRO Tools has 25 fasteners in 1/8 in and 25 in 3/16 in, the Cleco pliers that compress and set them, and a mesh carry bag. The sizes are color-coded, copper for 1/8 in and brass for 3/16 in, so you can sort them at a glance. Drill the holes to the standard sizes: a #30 drill (0.1285 in) for 1/8 in Clecos and a #10 drill (0.1935 in) for 3/16 in.

Get Cleco K4S50-1 kit

Corrosion between the panels: 3M Weld-Thru Coating II 05917

Once a lap joint or flange is welded, the two mating faces can never be painted again. That overlap is where repaired panels rust from the inside first. The 3M Weld-Thru Coating II 05917 is a zinc-rich aerosol in a 12.75 oz (361 g) can. 3M labels it for industrial/occupational use only, not for consumer sale or use. Its handling instructions say to avoid eye contact with vapors, mists or spray, not to breathe vapors, to avoid prolonged or repeated skin contact, not to eat, drink or smoke when using it, and to wash exposed areas thoroughly with soap and water. 3M states that the zinc corrodes in place of the steel it touches, so it keeps protecting the joint after welding. 3M’s directions also say that if you plan to MIG/MAG plug weld, remove the coating from the plug weld site before welding. 3M’s directions call for removing all surface contaminates from the mating flange areas with an abrasive, then blowing off and cleaning the surface with a VOC compliant surface cleaner, applying two light coats with 5 minutes flash time between coats, and letting the coating dry 10 to 15 minutes at room temperature before assembling. The SEM 40773 Zincweld, a 16 oz zinc aerosol, does the same job if you prefer it. When welding through the coating, weld with the work area ventilated and/or local forced ventilation at the arc, and wear an approved air-supplied respirator if ventilation is poor, as Hobart’s Handler 140EZ manual directs. The same manual says not to weld on coated metals, such as galvanized, lead, or cadmium plated steel, unless the coating is removed from the weld area, the area is well ventilated, and while wearing an air-supplied respirator, because the coatings and any metals containing these elements can give off toxic fumes if welded.

Get 3M Weld-Thru Coating II 05917

Optional: a resistance spot welder for flange joints

A resistance spot welder squeezes two overlapping sheets between copper tips and passes current until a nugget forms, much like the original factory weld, without filler wire. On door skins, pinch welds and other flanges you can reach from both sides, it makes plug welds unnecessary. Two layers of 18 gauge add up to about 0.096 in, so check whether a unit’s thickness rating is per sheet or for both sheets together. It is not needed for butt-welded patches or for any joint you can reach from only one side. Models are compared in best spot welders.

FAQ

Can I weld body panels with flux-core wire instead of gas?

The Hobart Handler 140EZ runs both, but the polarity changes: solid wire runs DCEP and flux-core runs DCEN. Flux-core leaves slag on every tack and plug weld, and you have to clean it off before the next pass. On 20 to 22 gauge steel, Hobart’s Handler 140EZ welding guide gives settings for solid wire with 75% argon/25% CO2 shielding gas.

Do I need the air punch if I already have a drill?

A drill and a 5/16 in bit can make the plug-weld holes. What a drill cannot make is the offset edge for a flush lap joint. The Astro Pneumatic 608PT makes both from shop air. If you plan only butt-welded patches, a drill covers the holes and you can skip the flange tool.

Does weld-through primer replace normal primer on the repair?

No. 3M Weld-Thru Coating II 05917 is meant for the faces that end up sandwiched inside the welded joint. After welding and dressing the seam, the outside of the repair still needs a normal primer system. Remove excess weld-through overspray from the outer panels with a mild VOC-compliant solvent before you apply it, as 3M directs.