ESAB vs Lincoln Electric: The Best Welder From Each, and Which to Buy
The one to buy is the ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC. It was picked on four criteria: how many processes one machine covers, AC TIG for aluminum, the input power it runs on, and the warranty. It welds MIG, flux-cored, stick, DC TIG and AC TIG, so it TIG welds aluminum. Lincoln’s POWER MIG 215 MPi is DC TIG only, and Lincoln rates its AC/DC all-rounder, the POWER MIG 220 AC/DC, at 230A at 15% for MIG and 210A at 20% for TIG on 240V; ESAB rates the Rebel at 205A at 25% for both. The Rebel plugs into 120V or 230V, ESAB rates it at 205A at 25% duty cycle for MIG on 230V, and ESAB backs it with a 3-year warranty.
Get ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DCThese picks were not tested. They rest on what ESAB and Lincoln Electric publish for each machine: rated output and duty cycle, processes, input power, weight, what comes in the box, and the warranty. Price is not one of the criteria, because ESAB’s US product pages publish no price to set against Lincoln’s list prices. The picks below are the one machine to buy from each maker for three common jobs, and which of the two wins each job.
The picks at a glance
| Job | ESAB pick | Lincoln pick | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| One machine for everything, aluminum TIG included | Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC | POWER MIG 220 AC/DC | ESAB |
| Mostly MIG on steel, with some stick and DC TIG | Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC | POWER MIG 215 MPi | Lincoln |
| TIG first, on steel, stainless and aluminum | Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC | Square Wave TIG 200 | ESAB |
| Heavier MIG in a shop | Rebel EMP 285ic | POWER MIG 260 | ESAB, unless the machine never moves |
The figures in every section are the maker’s own, from ESAB’s and Lincoln’s product pages and spec sheets for that exact model.
Best overall: ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC
Why it wins: it is the only machine on this page that runs MIG, flux-cored, stick, DC TIG and AC TIG from one box on household power. ESAB lists stick welding including cellulosic electrodes and says the Rebel will run 6010 rods on a 120V line.
The AC TIG side is complete, not a token. ESAB lists high-frequency starts, AC frequency adjustable from 25 to 400 Hz, AC balance from 60 to 90%, amplitude offset, dual current, and DC pulse up to 500 Hz. Those are the controls that decide how a bead on aluminum looks, and they are the reason to pick this machine over Lincoln’s POWER MIG 215 MPi for anyone who TIG welds aluminum, from trailer work to repairs.
The ratings. On 230V, ESAB rates the Rebel at 205A at 25% duty cycle for MIG and for TIG, and 170A at 25% for stick. On 120V it is 115A at 20% for MIG and 105A at 40% for TIG. ESAB gives a maximum plate thickness of 3/8 in.
What is in the box. ESAB ships it with a Tweco Fusion 180 MIG gun on a 10 ft cable, a Heliarc SR-17 TIG torch, a TIG foot control, a Victor regulator and gas hose, an electrode holder, a work clamp and a 230V-to-120V adapter. A buyer does not need to add a torch or pedal before welding TIG, which is not true of Lincoln’s base POWER MIG 215 MPi.
Build and warranty. It weighs 50 lb, sits in a five-handle roll cage and carries an IP23S enclosure rating. ESAB gives an operating temperature range of 14 to 104 °F (-10 to +40 °C). ESAB backs it with its Iron Clad Pledge and a 3-year warranty. For setup, ESAB’s sMIG feature has a basic mode that ESAB says makes setup simple for hobbyists, and it adapts to the operator’s technique in MIG.
Who should not buy it. Anyone who will never TIG aluminum pays for an AC side that sits unused. If the work is mostly MIG on steel, buy the Lincoln below.
Get ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DCBest Lincoln, and the pick for MIG-first work: Lincoln Electric POWER MIG 215 MPi
Why it wins its job: it carries more MIG output per minute of arc than the Rebel. Lincoln rates the POWER MIG 215 MPi at 215A at 30% duty cycle for MIG on 230V and 120A at 100%. The Rebel’s MIG rating is 205A at 25%. On 120V, Lincoln rates it at 105A at 40% for MIG, against the Rebel’s 115A at 20%. Lincoln’s manual lists solid wire from .025 to .035 in. and flux-cored wire from .030 to .045 in., the same limits ESAB gives the Rebel, and the output range on 230V runs from 20 to 220A DC.
What it does not do. Lincoln lists the processes as MIG, flux-cored, stick and DC TIG. There is no AC output, so it does not TIG weld aluminum. Lincoln’s answer for aluminum on this machine is MIG with a spool gun: the Aluminum One-Pak version (K4877-1) adds a Magnum PRO 100SG spool gun.
Setup help. Ready.Set.Weld recommends parameters for each procedure, ArcFX shows on screen how settings affect the weld, and settings can be saved to memory.
What is in the box. The base model (K4876-1) comes with a Magnum PRO 175L gun on a 10 ft cable, an electrode holder, a work cable and clamp, a regulator and hose, a 230V-to-120V adapter and a sample spool of SuperArc wire. The TIG torch and foot Amptrol are not in the base box; they come in the TIG One-Pak (K4878-1). It weighs 48 lb and Lincoln lists a 3-year warranty. Lincoln’s product page carries a California Proposition 65 warning: cancer and reproductive harm.
Who should buy it. Farm and ranch repair, light fabrication and anyone who runs mostly MIG and flux-core on steel, with stick for dirty or rusty steel (Lincoln rates the case IP21S and its manual limits it to indoor use in a dry location) and the occasional DC TIG weld on steel or stainless. Who should not: anyone who needs to TIG aluminum. Buy the Rebel instead.
Get Lincoln Electric POWER MIG 215 MPiBest for TIG: ESAB Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC
Why it wins: it carries the higher published TIG rating of the two TIG machines at full output and at 60% duty cycle, and it pulses AC and DC far faster. ESAB rates the Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC at 230A at 30% duty cycle for TIG on 230V, 163A at 60% and 126A at 100%. On 120V the TIG rating is 125A at 30%. Stick on 230V is rated at 180A at 30%.
Arc control. ESAB lists four AC waveforms (square, soft square, sinusoidal and triangle), AC and DC pulse up to 200 Hz, dual-current mode, and saved jobs recalled from the torch trigger, all set on a 5-inch color screen. A built-in power factor correction circuit keeps the arc stable on input cables up to 300 ft, by ESAB’s figure, which matters on a distant job-site panel. For extension cords, ESAB’s manual sets a 50 ft (15 m) maximum with at least a 13 AWG (2.5 mm²) grounding conductor.
In the box and on the scale. ESAB ships it with a Heliarc SR 26 TIG torch on a 13 ft cable, a foot pedal, a Victor regulator, an electrode holder, a work lead and a 120V/230V power adapter. It weighs 42 lb, and ESAB gives an operating temperature range of 14 to 104 °F (-10 to +40 °C). ESAB’s warranty table puts TIG power sources at 3 years; TIG torches carry 90 days.
Who should buy it. Anyone whose work is mostly TIG: aluminum, stainless, thin sheet, and anyone who wants room to grow into pulse and waveform settings. Who should not: anyone who also needs MIG. The Rogue does TIG and stick only; for one machine that does all of it, the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC above is the buy.
Get ESAB Rogue ET 230iP AC/DCLincoln’s TIG pick: Lincoln Electric Square Wave TIG 200
The Square Wave TIG 200 is Lincoln’s AC/DC TIG and stick machine for 120V and 230V. Lincoln rates it at 200A at 25% duty cycle for TIG on 230V, 160A at 40% and 130A at 60%. On 120V the TIG rating is 125A at 25%, and 110A at 25% for AC TIG. Stick on 230V is rated at 170A at 20%.
Lincoln publishes an AC frequency range of 60 to 150 Hz, AC balance of 60 to 90% electrode negative, and pulse from 0.1 to 20 pulses per second. It comes with a PTA-17F TIG torch, a foot Amptrol, a regulator/flowmeter and gas hose, a stick electrode holder, a ground clamp and both input cords. Lincoln lists the net weight at 46.5 lb and the warranty at 3 years. Lincoln’s product page carries a California Proposition 65 warning: cancer and reproductive harm.
Rogue or Square Wave? On the makers’ figures the Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC wins: 230A at 30% against 200A at 25%, 163A at 60% against 130A at 60%, pulse to 200 Hz against 20 pulses per second, and 42 lb against 46.5 lb. Lincoln aims the Square Wave TIG 200 at hobbyists, makers, small fabricators and craftsmen, with an interface Lincoln describes as set it, forget it and weld. Buy it if your welding supply services Lincoln and not ESAB, or if a short list of controls matters more to you than the extra amperage.
Get Lincoln Electric Square Wave TIG 200Best for heavier shop MIG: ESAB Rebel EMP 285ic
Why it wins: more rated output than Lincoln’s POWER MIG 260 at the same duty cycle, at well under a third of the weight, with stick and TIG as well. ESAB rates the single-phase model (120-240V input) at 285A at 40% duty cycle for MIG, 220A at 60% and 160A at 100%, with a maximum of 300A. The three-phase model (460-575V) is rated at 285A at 50% and 200A at 100%, with a maximum of 350A.
Wire and drive. ESAB’s four-roll drive takes solid wire up to .052 in. and flux-cored up to 1/16 in., on spools up to 12 in., and ESAB lists short-arc and spray transfer on .035 and .045 in. wire. It also runs stick electrodes up to 5/32 in. and DC TIG.
Portability. It weighs 70 lb and lifts off its cart, so the same machine works the bench and the job site. It comes with a Tweco Spray Master MIG gun on a 15 ft cable, an electrode holder, a ground clamp, a Victor regulator, a 110V adapter plug and sample wire and 7018 rods. ESAB’s warranty table puts MIG power sources at 3 years.
Who should buy it. A fabrication shop, trailer builder or maintenance crew running .045 in. wire for hours, who also wants to carry the machine to a repair. Who should not: a home garage doing repair and light fabrication. The Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC covers that work at 50 lb and adds AC TIG.
Get ESAB Rebel EMP 285icLincoln’s shop MIG: Lincoln Electric POWER MIG 260
The POWER MIG 260 is Lincoln’s MIG and flux-cored machine for light industrial fabrication, maintenance and repair. Lincoln rates it at 250A at 26.5V at 40% duty cycle, with an output range of 30 to 300A, and it takes single-phase input at 208, 230, 460 or 575V. It has a 7-inch color display, Ready.Set.Weld automatic settings, ArcFX, memory, a 115V outlet on the front and a tilting gas bottle tray, and Lincoln lists it as push-pull and spool gun ready for aluminum, with the guns sold separately. It ships with a Magnum PRO 250L gun on a 15 ft cable, a regulator and hose, a .035/.045 in. drive roll kit and work and power cables. Lincoln lists a net weight of 247 lb and a 3-year warranty. Lincoln’s product page carries a California Proposition 65 warning: cancer and reproductive harm.
Rebel 285ic or POWER MIG 260? The Rebel wins on the figures: 285A at 40% against 250A at 40%, 70 lb against 247 lb, and four processes against two. Buy the POWER MIG 260 for a MIG station that never leaves the shop floor, where the weight does not matter, the 7-inch screen and automatic settings suit a shared station, and push-pull aluminum is part of the work.
Get Lincoln Electric POWER MIG 260What is not worth the money
- AC TIG you will never use. If aluminum TIG is not on the list, the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC’s AC controls are money spent on nothing. The POWER MIG 215 MPi is the better MIG machine for that buyer.
- A shop machine for a home garage. The POWER MIG 260 weighs 247 lb and welds MIG and flux-core only. For home repair and light fabrication, either all-rounder above does the job at 48 to 50 lb and moves with you.
- A dedicated TIG machine when you also need MIG. Two machines cost more than one. Unless TIG is most of the work, the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC covers both.
How to choose between ESAB and Lincoln
The brand question is mostly a machine question. Decide what the work is, pick the machine that wins that job on the published ratings, and let the brand follow. Three things decide most choices.
1. Do you need AC TIG? Aluminum TIG needs AC output. The ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC has it and the Lincoln POWER MIG 215 MPi does not; Lincoln’s AC-capable all-rounder is the POWER MIG 220 AC/DC. If the answer is no, the POWER MIG 215 MPi’s higher MIG rating (215A at 30%, 120A at 100%) makes it the better buy.
2. How long do you weld without stopping? Duty cycle is the share of a ten-minute period a machine can weld at a given output. A 25% rating at 205A means about two and a half minutes of arc at that output before the machine needs to cool. For long beads on thick plate, compare the higher-duty-cycle figures, not the headline output: at 60%, ESAB rates the Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC at 163A against Lincoln’s 130A for the Square Wave TIG 200. Lincoln publishes only a 40% rating for the POWER MIG 260 (250A), against the Rebel EMP 285ic’s 285A at 40%.
3. What power do you have? The Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC, the POWER MIG 215 MPi, the Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC and the Square Wave TIG 200 all run on 120V and 230V, with full output only on 230V. The Rebel EMP 285ic single-phase model takes 120-240V and the three-phase model 460-575V. The POWER MIG 260 needs single-phase 208, 230, 460 or 575V.
Who makes them
Lincoln Electric was founded on December 5, 1895, in Cleveland, Ohio, and by 1911 John C. and James F. Lincoln had launched its first variable-voltage arc welder. ESAB was founded in Sweden in 1904 by engineer Oscar Kjellberg, who developed the first coated welding electrode that year. ESAB’s North American welding brands include Tweco guns and Victor gas equipment, which is why a Rebel arrives with a Tweco gun and a Victor regulator.
Warranty and service
Every machine on this page carries a 3-year warranty from its maker. ESAB’s warranty table lists 3 years for MIG, TIG and stick power sources, 90 days for MIG guns and TIG torches, and 90 days for foot and hand controls. Lincoln lists 3 years on the product page of each of its three machines here.
Service is local. Both makers sell through distributors, and each lists them on a where-to-buy locator. A supply house that carries the brand is the nearest source of contact tips, liners and gas, and the first stop for a warranty question. If the nearest one carries only one of the two brands, that is a fair reason to pick the runner-up machine of that brand over the winner of the other.
Consumables and parts
Gun and torch parts do not cross between the brands. The Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC ships with a Tweco Fusion 180 gun and Velocity contact tips; the POWER MIG 215 MPi ships with a Magnum PRO 175L gun and its own contact tips. Filler metal is different: wire and rods are sold to AWS classifications, so an ER70S-6 wire or a 7018 rod of the right diameter is not tied to the brand of the machine.
Choose ESAB if
- You want one machine that does MIG, stick and TIG on steel and aluminum: the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC.
- TIG is most of your work and you want the higher duty cycle and faster pulse: the Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC.
- You run heavy wire in a shop and still carry the machine to jobs: the Rebel EMP 285ic.
Choose Lincoln Electric if
- You mostly MIG weld steel and want the higher MIG rating: the POWER MIG 215 MPi.
- Your local supply services Lincoln, or you want the simpler TIG panel: the Square Wave TIG 200.
- You want a stationary MIG station with push-pull aluminum and a 7-inch screen: the POWER MIG 260.
For more brands in the same comparison, see Lincoln vs Miller vs Hobart. If this is your first machine, the best MIG welders for beginners guide covers smaller and cheaper options from both brands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better overall, ESAB or Lincoln?
For one machine that does everything, ESAB: the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC TIG welds aluminum on AC and is rated 205A at 25%, against 230A at 15% (MIG) and 210A at 20% (TIG) for Lincoln’s POWER MIG 220 AC/DC; Lincoln’s POWER MIG 215 MPi is DC TIG only. For a machine that mostly runs MIG on steel, Lincoln: the POWER MIG 215 MPi carries the higher MIG rating on 230V (215A at 30% duty cycle against the Rebel’s 205A at 25%), and Lincoln rates it at 120A at 100%.
Is ESAB as good as Lincoln Electric?
On the machines on this page, yes. ESAB’s Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC and Rebel EMP 285ic beat their Lincoln counterparts on the makers’ published ratings, and both makers put a 3-year warranty on these machines. Lincoln’s POWER MIG 215 MPi is the stronger machine for MIG-first work. For most buyers the practical difference is which brand the nearest welding supply stocks and services.
What are the best alternatives to ESAB welders?
Lincoln Electric is the closest like-for-like alternative: the POWER MIG 220 AC/DC against the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC, the Square Wave TIG 200 against the Rogue ET 230iP AC/DC, and the POWER MIG 260 against the Rebel EMP 285ic. Miller and Hobart are two other brands often compared with both.
Who makes ESAB welders?
ESAB makes them. Swedish engineer Oscar Kjellberg founded the company in 1904, the year he developed the first coated welding electrode. Its North American welder line includes the Rebel multi-process machines and the Rogue TIG and stick machines, and Tweco guns and Victor regulators, both ESAB brands, come in the box with several of them.
Does ESAB make its own welding wire and electrodes?
Yes. The Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC ships with a sample spool of ESAB OK AristoRod 12.50 wire, and the Rebel EMP 285ic with AristoRod wire and Atom Arc Acclaim 7018 stick electrodes. Lincoln does the same with a sample spool of its SuperArc mild steel MIG wire in the POWER MIG 215 MPi box. Filler metal is sold to AWS classifications, so the right type and diameter runs in either brand’s machine.
How do ESAB and Lincoln compare for beginners?
Both overall picks suit a first machine. The Lincoln POWER MIG 215 MPi uses Ready.Set.Weld, which recommends settings for each procedure, and ArcFX, which shows on screen how a setting change affects the weld. The ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC has sMIG with a basic mode that ESAB says makes setup simple for hobbyists. A beginner who only needs MIG on steel gets more from the Lincoln; one who wants to learn TIG on aluminum needs an AC/DC machine: the ESAB Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC or Lincoln’s POWER MIG 220 AC/DC.
Are ESAB and Lincoln parts interchangeable?
No. Each ships with its own gun and tips: the Rebel EMP 205ic AC/DC with a Tweco Fusion 180 gun and Velocity contact tips, the POWER MIG 215 MPi with a Magnum PRO 175L gun and its own contact tips. Buy contact tips, nozzles and liners for the gun on your machine.
Related Articles
- Lincoln vs Miller vs Hobart — expanded brand comparison including Miller and Hobart
- Miller vs Hobart — the ITW family rivalry explained
- Best Multi-Process Welders Under $1000 — cheaper multi-process machines
- Best Stick Welders — stick machines compared